The East Asian Industrial Policy Experience: Implications for the Middle East

by Marcus Noland, Peterson Institute for International Economics
and Howard Pack, Wharton School

December 2005

Marcus NolandIndustrial policy was not the key to the rapid growth that Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan experienced in the second half of the 20th century. Benefits from the promotion of specific sectors and activities were modest at best, and they came with two unintended side effects: encouragement of corruption and discouragement of skill acquisition by the financial system. The East Asian experience reflected exceptional circumstances not likely to be reproduced, and the adoption of similar policies elsewhere today will not generate the past results the East Asians attained. In addition to the historically specific and irreproducible aspects of the East Asian experience, the tightened rules embodied in today's global system impede the implementation of policies applied by the East Asians a generation ago. So does the East Asian experience have any positive lessons for the Middle East? Yes, the fundamental message does: Improvements in the macroeconomic, microeconomic, and institutional dimensions of the economic environment, including the retention of highly skilled citizens and, ultimately, reversal of the brain drain, are more likely to accelerate growth and enhance welfare than "picking winner" strategies.

View full document [pdf]


Peterson Perspective: Sanctions on Iran: Why They Worked and Why a 'Snapback' May Not Work July 29, 2015

Op-ed: To Save Egypt's Economy, Move Quickly June 30, 2013

Article: Economic Sanctions Against Iran: Is the Third Decade a Charm? July 2012

Book: The Arab Economies in a Changing World, Second Edition November 2011

Op-ed: Arab Spring Will Not See an Economic Boom February 21, 2011

Paper: Recommendations to Revive Regional Integration in the Maghreb May 29, 2008

Book: A US-Middle East Trade Agreement:
A Circle of Opportunity?
November 2006

Policy Brief 04-4: Islam, Globalization, and Economic Performance in the Middle East June 2004

Working Paper 05-5: Explaining Middle Eastern Authoritarianism June 2005
Revised June 2006

© 2016 Peter G. Peterson Institute for International Economics. 1750 Massachusetts Avenue, NW.
Washington, DC 20036. Tel: 202-328-9000 Fax: 202-659-3225 / 202-328-5432
Site development and hosting by Digital Division